Max Haberstroh
The great game for a higher purpose (Part II)
In defiance of the non-violent power of form
Max Haberstroh
The great game for a higher purpose (Part II)
In defiance of the non-violent power of form
Max Haberstroh
The great game for a higher purpose (Part II)
In defiance of the non-violent power of form
Five years ago, we found ourselves welcoming New Year 2021 with that notorious 'hard lockdown', an exceptionally drastic measure to combat Covid-19. After all, 'the pandemic' kept us on the go from 2020 through 2023.
Using Covid-19 as the recurrent theme, this essay (no AI support) wants to extrapolate to our time Faust's human drama.The focus on Travel & Tourism may identify major aberrations, but also offers new chances for a sector at the crossroads: Either we really mean our own claim to concretize 'meaningfulness', assuming mutual responsibility in Tourism, or we continue to just pay lip-service to sustainability and solidarity, while serving mainly monetary rules. In this case, Travel & Tourism, divested of its 'soul', would be going deeply 'Faustian'.
Part II (of V) puts Faust's hubris, illusions and restlessness in the context of our time. The more we discover the more doubts emerge, and we are never satisfied. Violent attempts to create paradise on Earth mostly end up in calamities and destruction.Tourism tries with marketing and promotion – the risk to end up in overtourism and disillusion is real. However, there are natural patterns to follow.
The 'Faustian' play
Rather than representing a special character, Faust epitomizes essential traits of modern mankind and its society. He reveals motives and driving forces of our life that we mostly do not see. We may think differently, but our views and ideas of the world are largely determined by Faustian dynamics and restlessness. We experience them in our inability to relax – not in everyday-life, and not even on holidays. Media-savvy influencers tell us why, how, when to do what, for nothing else but to be part of the scene. We cover our body with tatoos, evocative as they are and faithful as they remain. While physical beauty fades away, beauty parlours fail to upgrade our facial attractiveness to the level of ‘Dorian Gray’s Portrait’ (Oscar Wilde). A false beauty anyway it is, in exchange of one’s precious soul.
Our hunt for eternal youth and desperate attempts to reorganize and ‘optimize’ our lives, in a false approach to 'higher purpose', make us blind for everything our present time offers. Mephisto, the devil’s smart messenger, describes this ‘Faustian poorness’ as follows: “No bliss satisfied him, no enjoyment, and so he tried to catch at shifting forms …”.
Faust went the way to nihilism – and perishes, because he has used the spirit of the artificial, borrowed from Mephisto, to devastate the heart of a sincere young woman – Margaret – and the lives of simple people. The dilemma of the Faustian world is that it cannot but exclude all forms of modest and grateful common life with nature. Consequently, the Faustian human being loses calmness, the condition for gratefulness and goodwill.
Faustian unlimited aspirations follow the order: “Enrich yourself!” Its ideology of an hedonistic casino-capitalism has little in common with socio-ecologically committed free market economies. Yet in order to make the difference, it is hardly useful to impose high-flying virtues, so long as we do not perceive and attack the destructive dynamics of modern life within our society and inside ourselves. Faust, as Goethe describes him, is a vivid epitome of this dynamism.
Over the years Travel & Tourism offered us the golden platform to discover the world, adapted to both high and low-budget travellers. The former were considered as ‘privileged’ and intentional, the latter preferably labelled as ‘bargain hunters’, with an unerring eye for ‘last-minute’ opportunities. Travel destinations were opening up at high-speed, attracting tourists by means of advertising and sales promotion – an instrumentation that was increasingly focused on selected target-groups, particular life-styles and new Tourism zones.
It is hard to overlook parallels: Faust wants to reshape the whole world to make it people’s paradise. Not as a gardener, who wisely channels nature’s unfolding, but as a blaster, whose sense of development is exploitation. His wish fulfilled would make Faust equal to God. However, his vision will never come entirely true, since its final fulfillment will be subject to a future which always just promises fulfillment, without allowing itself to happen at present. The highest moment Faust can savour is nothing but “anticipating the deep enjoyment” of future happiness, which never a man will experience.
God's rematch of the 'Faustian' Play
Edgar Mitchell, astronaut on Apollo 14, comments his space flight in January, 1971 (‘The Home Planet’): “The peaks were the recognition that it is a harmonious, purposeful, creating universe. The valleys came in recognizing that humanity wasn’t behaving in accordance with that knowledge.” –
Referring to the Fall of Humanity that terminated Paradise on Earth, Archangel Uriel recites to Adam and Eve in Haydn's Oratorium of the Creation: "O happy pair, and ever happy henceforth", if you will refrain from wanting to have, or wishing to know, more than you should." Is it a coincidence that Haydn's libertine Archangel Uriel, ambiguous, creative and full of energy, and Goethe's Faust share some features of ambiguous characters? And what about us? The more we discover and explore and conquer, the more we cannot but keep asking and having doubts. Is this God's merciful rematch of the ‘Faustian’ play?
In its good or evil sense, our nature is ‘Faustian’: ‘Looking to see’ has often been just the prelude to ‘crossing the fence', to see and experience what is out there. And to keep eyes open and ears alert: Too often Cassandra's warnings have been left unheard and taken as little more than just unpleasant wake-up calls. Vulcanologists know better: There is no excuse for political sleepwalkers, as early symptoms have kept rising. Vigilance is worth it.
Space is now open for Tourism. With new dimensions turning our view from earth to space and from space to earth, we can’t stop watching, asking, being amazed, overwhelmed, and seaching higher purpose, as …
… The sight of it gives Angels power
Though none can understand the way,
And all your noble work is ours,
As bright as on the primal day (Faust: Three Archangels, Prologue in Heaven).
At the end of his life, Faust expresses our erstwhile untarnished belief in progress, rooted in omnipotence and omniscience. The former allows unlimited desire and fulfillment, the latter provides total control. Unifying both of them would mean the total form of man’s freedom in the sense of absolute autonomy toward nature and God. The promise of the snake in the Genesis of the Bible would be fulfilled: “Your will be like God”.–
We may shy away from largely identifying ourselves with Faust. A clear attention to what we are doing and its consequences is the basis of our's and our society’s self-knowledge. Nothing less than our way of life is at stake. This self-knowledge may remind us of the motto of the antique oracle of Delphi, “Know Yourself”. Its meaning intends to tell us that we are all humans, but not God.
Form follows function
Travel & Tourism spearheads people’s yearnings on the way to free travelling, enjoying leisure and pleasure, sports and adventure, arts and culture, new insights and viewpoints. In a time of manipulation, plagiarism, fake news, populism and virtual hate-speech, Tourism evokes the natural and the pristine, the artistic and the unique highlights of both world heritage and their ‘Disney’-inspired artificial worlds. But there is the other side: We understand local people’s growing reluctance to welcome visitors, since there are simply too many of them. The problems they create affect the quality of local everyday-life and culture, pushing the prices for consumer goods and real-estate assets, lowering the levels of behaviour, and rising social and environmental degradation and crime rates. Man’s concept of an artificial Tourism world may be perfect – technically and in functional terms. However, it remains a surrogate, a kind of “second-hand world” (Ludwig Fusshoeller/The Return of the Demons).
For decades, we have degraded natural places of beauty and charm to deserts of concrete and steel – materials that insinuate duration, yet brought deception. Our dreams and ambitions to turn into man-made holiday paradises seemingly useless areas in mountains, valleys and on coastlines, too often left dreams back and paradise – lost. This went at a high price paid to pressurize on tourism development and put up with mass-tourism, in an effort to reach a quick return of investment: “To gold they tend, On gold depend, All things! Oh, poverty!” (Goethe, Faust I).
After decades of people almost having gotten used to ‘bed fortresses’, it is time to say good-bye to an architecture which nobody likes. New ideas were coming up, for instance that 'smart beats hard': 'Smart City' concepts have started to being implemented in the early 2000s, soon adapted to face an emerging mass-tourism. An example is the concept of the ‘Tourist City’. It is intended to provide benefits for both the visitor and the local inhabitant and intends to further develop holistically the 'Smart City' approach, in an effort to make towns and cities economically more efficient, socially more inclusive, and ecologically 'more green'.
Far away from turning into a tourist ghetto, the ‘Tourist City’ has three different expressions: first, as tourism resorts, including accommodation and all kinds of pastime activities for the visitor; second, as an integral part of important tourist cities boasting a particular cultural and historical identity, and whose annual tourist arrivals exceed distinctly the number of inhabitants; third, as ‘restructured’ cities, which provide special tourism-related areas within a city otherwise unlikely to be frequented by non-locals.
In a strictly functional sense, ‘Form follows function’ , the functional 'Bauhaus' architecture provided the template. Since its beginnings after World War I, the Bauhaus has brought together numerous important protagonists from the worlds of art and handicraft, architecture and many other disciplines. They not only ought to create everyday objects, but to play an active role in re-shaping society. Space for nature became tight, as the number of inhabitants was increasing – and the number of visitors, too:
“It’s in the very nature of the thing:
For the natural the world has barely space:
What’s artificial commands a narrow place.”
(Faust II, Laboratory)'
Natural patterns to follow
In view of his 19th century explorations in South America and Russia, Alexander von Humboldt serves as a shiny example of looking at things from a different angle: Having dedicated his life to cross-disciplinary scientific research, he ignored any distinction between natural science and humanities. He branded his book "Kosmos" as a composition of reason and emotion, and evoked the natural pattern as a system of best practice, both in management and architecture.
Less survival nature itself has no purpose, no goal, nor will. Attaining biological maturity, the ‘natural system’ follows natural fits which complement and supplement one another. Being ‘organic’ rather than organizational, the natural system points to the deficiencies of Man’s ‘cocooning’ tendencies to avoid risks, which, rather than acting in a more holistic way, generally follow sharply defined functions and strongly centralized hierarchical structures.
In his bestseller ‘Against the Gods – The Remarkable Story of Risk’, Peter L. Bernstein asks “… What are the prospects … that we can hope to bring more risks under control and make progress at the same time?” He points out that “the answer must focus on Leibniz’ admonition of 1703: ‘Nature has established patterns originating in the return of events, but only for the most part.’ … That qualification is the key to the whole story. Without it, there would be no risk, for everything would be predictable. Without it, there would be no change, for every event would be identical to a previous event. Without it, life would have no mystery.”
Looking at the rich biodiversity which we ourselves are a part of, however, we may conclude that natural organism is far more apt than man-made organization, to manage complexity and even to ‘economize by creating abundance’. Admittedly, this sounds paradox. In all its varied abundance, nature stands for self-sufficiency, complementary impact, ecological economy, diversification and decentralization.
Nature has developed a systemic way of complementary properties between species, and an instinct that even includes cooperative elements reminding us of human ‘solidarity’. ‘Eco-Tourism’, for instance, enters a sensitive liaison with nature, following its kind invitation to let us be enchanted by its rich biodiversity, if we do not abuse it. Travel & Tourism, the industry, is well advised to dive more profoundly into the depth of ‘bionic construction and management’, to apply its strategies on how to grow and flourish, to compete and cooperate, and to learn how to economize by creating abundance.
Function follows the non-violent power of ... form
Goethe's original 'Faust' draft was called 'Urfaust', a kind of prototype of the famous drama. 'Urfaust' was given as a benevolent nickname to Hans Domizlaff, who started his career as an advertiser during the Roaring Twenties. The ‘Master of Brands’, as he was also dubbed later, became a brillant creator of Industrial brands and interpreter of political symbolism. He projected the entrepreneurial wisdom of nature to human psychology and called it “Markentechnik”, or Branding Technique, emphasising the corporate style to be coherent, with its components designed as vectors of the company’s concept.
Domizlaff refers to the natural pattern: “At first, a brand is just an idea, but then it becomes a living creature, an organism on its own" (from: ‘Die Gewinnung des öffentlichen Vertrauens’/‘Winning Public Confidence’).
In terms of State Branding, Domizlaff insists: “With regards to meaning, however, form should not follow function, it ought to be an expression of the state system. The ‘invisible’, non-violent power of form could rule people much better than physical violence or restricting laws.”
As a tribute to his 'Urfaust' token, Domizlaff himself reveals some 'Faustian' thinking: He concludes that “if being determines consciousness, then someone who designs people’s being, will determine people’s consciousness”. He understood his well-meant approach beneficial for Germany's democracy ('Weimar Republic'), yet main political stakeholders' vigilance device seemed out of order.
In 1932, Domizlaff tried to convince the German government to install a state 'propaganda' unit (today we would call it Information and Promotion Department, or alike). It would have been in charge of communicating the assets of a then struggling democracy, which was facing an avalanche of challenges after World War I and the 1929 Great Depression. However, there was no understanding and perhaps no will to catch the spirit of a non-violent 'Branded State'. Instead, Domizlaff's book 'Propagandamittel der Staatsidee'/Propaganda Tools of the State Idea had caught the attention of an unintended but highly interested reader: the nazi propaganda minister Josef Goebbels ...
"What hidden sense in this enigma lies?" asks Faust. Mephisto's response: "I am the spirit, ever, that denies! ... Destruction, in short, what you’ve meant by evil is my true element."
Part III points to our struggle to prevent and heal the negative impacts of Travel & Tourism, with meager results, though. The industry seems too fragmented, stakeholders too ego-centered, and people too easygoing or pretentious to make ends meet. Depite its numerous workforce and an outstanding, yet by far not fully developed capacity to communicate and make networks, Travel & Tourism needs to address a more holistic approach, in order to be stuck in its ambiguous dead end of being overrated 'and' underexposed.-- Stay tuned.
The authors are responsible for the choice and presentation of the facts contained in this document and for the opinions expressed therein, which are not necessarily those of Tourism and Society Think Tank and do not commit the Organization, and should not be attributed to TSTT or its members.
This site uses cookies from Google to deliver its services and to analyze traffic. Information about your use of this site is shared with Google. By using this site, you agree to its use of cookies.